Less Than Lethal Self Defense Options
The information provided herein is solely for informational purposes and should not be construed as legal advice. The use of force law can vary significantly based on jurisdiction, circumstances, and specific legal interpretations. It is strongly advised that individuals seek the counsel of a qualified legal expert or attorney to obtain accurate and tailored guidance regarding the application of use of force laws in their particular situation. Reliance on any information presented without professional consultation is done so at one's own risk, and no liability shall be assumed for any consequences arising from such reliance.
By clicking on links, you support my continued work. Thank you.
Not every problem is a "gun" problem; in fact, most problems aren't. When it comes to self-defense, having less-than-lethal options at hand can provide safer, more effective ways to protect ourselves without the commitment or consequences of lethal force. If you carry a firearm for self- defense, remember brandishing your gun can get you in trouble in many states.
Whether it’s a flashlight, pepper spray, personal alarm, or even a tool like the Byrna gun, there are excellent options for situations where awareness and preparation can make all the difference. One of the most important and versatile tools, a good flashlight, deserves special attention. Read on as we delve into why every self-defense plan should start with the right flashlight—and how to choose one that fits your needs---as well as what other self-defense options provide.
1- Flashlight
A well-made flashlight is an incredibly versatile tool that should be within reach at all times. It prepares you for emergencies, enhances your safety, aids in various tasks, and adds convenience to your daily life. Most importantly, a flashlight contributes to your overall situational awareness. A side note here: the flashlight app on cell phones is not synonymous with the tool we are discussing. Too often, people rely on their phones, scrolling through apps to find the "flashlight" function. They do this while keeping their heads down. This is dangerous on multiple levels. In contrast, having a dedicated flashlight allows you to quickly grab it with one hand, turn it on, and immediately assess the situation without distraction.
When carrying a flashlight for self-defense, quick and easy access is essential. It should be stored in a way that allows immediate use (ideally with your non-gun hand), such as in a pocket or an easily accessible section of a purse. While your flashlight doesn’t need to be expensive, it should be bright, compact, one handed operational and comfortable enough for you to carry it daily. [If it’s not convenient to carry, you’re less likely to do so consistently—and a flashlight you don’t carry consistently won’t be useful when you need it most.]
A powerful flashlight can be an effective deterrent. Remember, a bad guy doesn’t want to spend too much time, get caught, or get hurt. A bright, disorienting light can give you the critical moment you need to create space and get away without causing harm. Not every situation that requires light will also require a gun, and there’s no harm in shining a light to see what’s happening. If you’re in a dark place, it’s reasonable to use a flashlight to identify what someone may have in their hands or what they’re doing. However, it’s not reasonable to point a pistol-mounted light at them unless the situation escalates.
To help you choose the right flashlight, let’s break down the essential parts of a quality tactical flashlight.
[NOTE: The Transportation Security Administration (TSA) regards flashlights as tools and advises that flashlights under seven inches can be carried in either a carry-on or checked bag. If the flashlight is larger than that, it must be packed in checked luggage. Lithium-ion batteries like CR123As carried outside a device are not allowed by the TSA. Loose spare batteries should be stowed away into your check-in baggage to prevent them from being confiscated. Some flashlights have a very aggressive bezel which the TSA can interpret as a weapon and not allow on a plane.]
The Anatomy of a Flashlight
Lens: The lens is the transparent cover at the front of the flashlight that protects the bulb or LED and helps focus or disperse the light beam. Some lenses are made of tough materials like tempered glass to withstand impacts.
Reflector: The reflector is a component inside the head of the flashlight that surrounds the bulb or LED. Its purpose is to gather and reflect light forward, enhancing the beam's intensity and focus.
Bezel: The bezel is the outer ring or lip around the lens. It serves multiple functions, including protecting the lens from scratches, providing a grip surface for twisting to focus the beam (if applicable), and sometimes incorporating features like crenellations for self-defense purposes.
Head/LED Housing: This is the main body of the flashlight where the LED or bulb is housed, along with the reflector and lens. In more advanced flashlights, this area may also contain electronic components for adjusting brightness levels or activating different modes.
Battery Compartment: The battery compartment is where you insert and store the batteries that power the flashlight. It's usually located in the handle or body of the flashlight and may have a cap or cover that screws on to secure the batteries in place.
Pocket Clip: The pocket clip is a metal or plastic clip attached to the flashlight body, allowing you to clip the flashlight to your pocket, belt, or gear for easy carrying and access.
Tail Cap: The tail cap is the end of the flashlight opposite the head. It typically screws onto the body and houses the switch or button used to turn the flashlight on and off. Having a tail switch on a tactical flashlight offers several advantages over a switch located on the body of the flashlight.
Tail Switch: The tail switch is the button or switch located on the tail cap. It controls the flashlight's operation, such as turning it on/off, activating different modes (e.g., strobe, low/high beam), or adjusting brightness levels.
Flashlight Ring: A flashlight ring is an optional accessory that can be attached to the flashlight's body, usually near the head or tail. It provides additional grip and stability, especially when using the flashlight in tactical or high-intensity situations.
Understanding elements like hotspot, spill, throw beam, flood beam, lumens, candela, watts, and lux will help you to select a flashlight that meets your specific needs. Each of these factors plays a unique role in how the flashlight performs. By familiarizing yourself with these terms, you will be better at choosing a flashlight that delivers what you need for your application.
Hotspot and Spill:
Hotspot: The hotspot is the central, most intense part of the flashlight beam. It's where the majority of the light output is concentrated, resulting in a focused and brighter area. The hotspot is useful for illuminating distant objects or focusing light on a specific point with high intensity.
Spill: The spill refers to the outer area of the beam surrounding the hotspot. It contains less concentrated light compared to the hotspot but still provides illumination over a wider area. The spill is essential for peripheral vision and general area lighting, making it easier to navigate and observe surroundings.
Flood vs. Throw:
Flood Beam: A flood beam is characterized by a wide and evenly distributed light pattern. It illuminates a broad area with uniform brightness, making it ideal for tasks that require close-range visibility, such as reading, camping, or working in a confined space. Flood beams are also useful for general-purpose lighting and enhancing peripheral vision.
Throw Beam: A throw beam is focused and projects light over a longer distance with greater intensity. It creates a concentrated hotspot that can reach far distances, making it suitable for outdoor activities like hiking, search and rescue operations, or tactical situations where long-range visibility is crucial. Throw beams penetrate through darkness effectively, allowing users to spot objects at a distance.
Flashlights designed for specific purposes often feature adjustable beams or multiple modes to switch between flood and throw settings, allowing users to adapt the light output based on their needs and environment.
Flashlight Brightness Measurements
Lumens: quantify total light output.
Candelas: measure the intensity and focus of the beam.
Watts: indicate electrical power consumption (historically correlated with brightness but less relevant with LED technology).
Lux: quantifies brightness per unit area at a specific distance.
When discussing how powerful a flashlight is, most people focus on lumens. Lumens measure the total brightness a light source produces—the higher the lumens, the brighter the light. However, lumens alone don’t tell the full story. A flashlight’s ability to illuminate effectively also depends on its design, including the reflective surfaces in the head and the lens, which direct the beam of light. This is where candela comes in.
Candela measures the intensity of a focused light beam, which determines how well the light can penetrate through light pollution or other visual barriers without being washed out. A flashlight with a high candela value and low lumens typically has a very tight, focused beam (hotspot) with minimal spill—useful in certain scenarios but not ideal for self-defense. On the other hand, a flashlight with low candela and high lumens may create a broad, diffused light (like a floodlight), which also isn’t ideal for self-defense situations.
For self-defense purposes, the goal is a flashlight that balances reach and spill. You need a beam that can illuminate a potential threat clearly, allowing you to see their hands and identify whether they pose an active threat. At the same time, the beam should provide enough spill to illuminate the surrounding area, helping you identify any accomplices or bystanders. This balance ensures you can make informed decisions in a critical situation.
Putting it all together
This is a lot of information so let’s summarize this to help you make the right decision. You need:
A size you can easily carry. Approximately 4”-5” long and 1” thick.
Power source CR123A or Rechargeable 18650 batteries.
Simple operation. No need to program your light. On/Off tail switch will be sufficient.
An approximate 1 to 20 ratio of Lumens to Candelas. This will give you a good combination of total output to focus beam. Example 550 Lumens and 10,250 Candelas will give you a crisp hotspot and sufficient spill.
FOR OUR RECOMMENDATIONS ON QUALITY FLASHLIGHTS CLICK HERE
2. Pepper Spray and OC (Oleoresin Capsicum) Spray:
Though often used interchangeably, “pepper spray” and “OC spray” have subtle differences in formulation and application.
Chemical Composition:
Pepper Spray: This term broadly covers sprays containing capsaicin, the active component in chili peppers, and may include various additional chemicals or irritants.
OC Spray: Specifically refers to sprays made from oleoresin capsicum (OC), an oily resin extracted from hot peppers. OC is the active ingredient in most pepper sprays and is responsible for the intense irritation to the eyes, skin, and respiratory system.
Strength and Formulation:
OC Concentration and Scoville Heat Units (SHU): The effectiveness of both types of spray depends on the OC concentration (typically 2-10%) and SHU rating, which measures heat intensity. While higher SHU ratings indicate stronger effects, very high OC percentages can sometimes slow dispersal.
Additional Irritants: Some pepper sprays include CS tear gas or UV dye for added impact or identification, though these additives may not be legal everywhere. Pure OC sprays generally avoid these additives and may have fewer legal restrictions.
Effectiveness:
OC Spray: Known for its reliability against both people and animals, OC spray causes involuntary eye closure, inflammation, and breathing difficulty.
Pepper Spray (General): As a broader category, the effectiveness of pepper spray can vary depending on the OC concentration and any additional chemicals included.
By understanding these differences and selecting a product with the right OC concentration and SHU rating, you can choose a spray that best suits your needs for effective, legal self-defense.
3. Pepper spray (traditional spray) VS Pepper gel.
A. Dispersion and Range
Pepper Spray: Traditional pepper spray disperses in a mist or stream, which can spread over a wider area. It typically has a range of 8-12 feet. While this can create a larger "cloud" of defense, it also increases the risk of blowback if there’s wind, potentially affecting the user.
Pepper Gel: Gel has a thicker consistency, which allows for a more precise, focused stream that can reach further—often up to 18 feet. Gel sticks to the target more effectively and is less likely to blow back on the user in windy conditions.
B. Indoor vs. Outdoor Use
Pepper Spray: Since spray disperses into the air, it’s not ideal for indoor use, as it can affect bystanders and remain in the air for a while.
Pepper Gel: Because it is less airborne, pepper gel is better for indoor settings and confined spaces, reducing the risk of affecting unintended people.
C. Accuracy and Containment
Pepper Spray: This is ideal for creating a larger area of defense, but it’s less accurate due to its misting effect and greater vulnerability to wind.
Pepper Gel: Gel is more precise and sticky making it easier to aim directly at an attacker without affecting the surrounding area. This makes it suitable for close quarters or when you need to avoid contaminating your environment.
D. Cleanup and Residue
Pepper Spray: Residual spray can remain in the air or on surfaces, which may require additional cleanup and caution for any surfaces touched by the mist.
Pepper Gel: Gel adheres to the target and is less likely to contaminate surfaces around it, though it may require careful handling if residue is left on clothing or skin.
Summary
Pepper Spray is effective for quick defense outdoors with a misting effect that can cover a broader area, but it risks blowback and is less suitable for enclosed spaces.
Pepper Gel provides more accuracy, longer range, and reduced contamination risk, making it ideal for both outdoor and indoor use.
4. Pepper Gel/Spray and Other Self Defense Options
A- Pepper Gel- SABRE Pepper Gel with Fast Flip Top, Maximum Strength OC Spray, Snap Clip for Easy Carry and Fast Access, Finger Grip for More Accurate and Faster Aim, UV Marking Dye, 0.54 fl oz, Easy to Use Safety
B- Pepper Gel for Runners/hikers- SABRE Runner Pepper Gel, Maximum Police Strength OC Spray, Reflective Hand Strap for Easy Carry & Quick Access, 0.67 fl oz, Secure & Easy to Use Safety, Optional Clip-On Alarm & LED Armband Combos.
C- Pepper Gel with a Lite- SABRE PepperLight 2-in-1 Flashlight Pepper Spray, Ultra-Bright 750 Lumen Flashlight, Visible Up To 540-Feet (165-Meters), Protect Aginst Multiple Threats with 25 Bursts, IPX6 Water-Resistant Rated.
D- Pepper Gel (spray) with a Personal alarm- 3-in-1 Pepper Spray Self Defence Personal Alarm Set for Women, Max Strength Pepper Gel & 130 dB Safety Alarms & Strobe Lights, Quick Release, 3X Protection, Canister Replaceable.
E- Pepper Spray with GPS- SABRE Smart Bluetooth Pepper Spray for Self Defense w/Live GPS Tracking, Text & Phone Call Alerts in Emergencies, Fast Flip Top, Training Spray, Refill Canister Available, 0.54 fl oz.
E- Large canister for Distance SABRE Frontiersman 9.2 fl oz. Bear Spray, Maximum Strength 2.0% Major Capsaicinoids, Powerful 35 ft. Range Bear Deterrent, Outdoor Camping & Hiking Protection, Quick Draw Holster & Multipack Options.
F.- Large Canister Pepper Gel- SABRE Red Home Defense Pepper Gel With Wall Mount For Easy Access, Max Strength OC Spray, UV Marking Dye Helps Identify Suspects, Full Hand Grip For More Accurate Aim, Secure Pin Safety, 32 Bursts.
NOTE:- When traveling via air, one 4 fl. oz. (118 ml) container of mace or pepper spray is permitted in checked baggage provided it is equipped with a safety mechanism to prevent accidental discharge. Self-defense sprays containing more than 2 percent by mass of tear gas (CS or CN) are prohibited in checked baggage.
Pepper spray is legal in all 50 states for self-defense, but each state has specific regulations on its use, size limits, strength, and permissible age for possession. Here’s an overview of some general guidelines:
A. Size and Strength Restrictions: Many states regulate the volume of pepper spray that can be carried. For example, in California, the canister size limit is 2.5 ounces, while New York restricts strength and requires pepper spray to be purchased from licensed firearms dealers or pharmacies.
B. Age Requirements: Most states require users to be at least 18 years old to purchase or carry pepper spray, though exceptions can apply.
C. Permits and Purchasing Restrictions: States like New York and Massachusetts require residents to purchase pepper spray only from specific in-state retailers.
D. Michigan and Wisconsin have restrictions on strength and types of tear gas or pepper spray, requiring sprays to contain only OC (oleoresin capsicum).
E. Usage for Self-Defense Only: In nearly all states, pepper spray is legal only for self-defense purposes. Misuse, such as using it offensively or in situations unrelated to self-defense, can lead to legal penalties.
4. Stun Gun
A stun gun is a handheld, non-lethal self-defense tool designed to incapacitate an attacker by delivering a high-voltage, low-amperage electrical charge. The goal is to temporarily disrupt the attacker’s muscular control and cause disorientation, providing you with an opportunity to escape or seek help. A stun gun is a reliable, easy-to-use self-defense tool for those seeking a non-lethal option to protect themselves. While it requires close contact to be effective, it can provide a powerful deterrent and incapacitate an attacker long enough to escape or call for help.
How a Stun Gun Works
Electric Shock: The stun gun emits an electrical charge when its metal prongs make contact with the target’s body. This charge interferes with the body's neuromuscular functions, causing pain, muscle contractions, and temporary immobilization.
Proximity: Stun guns are contact weapons, meaning they must physically touch the target to be effective. This requires close-range deployment.
Key Features of Stun Guns
Compact and Portable:
Often small enough to fit in a pocket, purse, or holster.
Lightweight and easy to carry discreetly.
Ease of Use:
Requires minimal training to operate.
Activation usually involves pressing a button or switch when the prongs are in contact with the target.
Non-lethal:
Designed to incapacitate without causing permanent harm.
Additional Features:
Some models include built-in flashlights for added utility.
Rechargeable batteries or replaceable battery options.
Benefits of Using a Stun Gun
Effective Deterrent: The loud crackling sound of a stun gun’s charge can often intimidate an attacker and prevent a confrontation before it begins.
Immediate Effect: Provides instant results when deployed properly, causing pain, disorientation, and temporary loss of control.
Non-lethal Option: Ideal for individuals seeking a self-defense tool that minimizes the risk of fatal harm.
Legal Accessibility: Generally legal in many areas, though restrictions vary by state or country.
Limitations of Stun Guns
Close-Range Use: Requires direct physical contact with the target, which may be challenging in certain situations.
Limited Effectiveness: May be less effective on individuals under the influence of drugs, alcohol, or in cases of extreme adrenaline.
Legal Restrictions: Not legal in all jurisdictions; always check local laws before purchasing or carrying a stun gun.
Best Practices for Using a Stun Gun
Practice Handling: Familiarize yourself with the device’s controls and operation to ensure quick and effective use in an emergency.
Situational Awareness: Use in combination with situational awareness to avoid close encounters whenever possible.
Target Key Areas: Aim for areas like the torso, thighs, or arms for maximum effect.
Stun Gun Options
A. Stun Gun with Pepper Spray and Light: SABRE Self-Defense Kit with Pepper Spray and Stun Gun with Flashlight, 25 Bursts, 10-Foot (3-Meter) Range, Painful µC Charge, 120 Lumens, Rechargeable Battery, Safety Switch.
B. Light With Stun Gun: SABRE 2-in-1 Tactical Stun Gun with LED Flashlight, Self Defense Stun Gun with 2.517 µC Charge Produces Intolerable Pain, 130 Lumen LED Light, Safety Switch, Belt Holster, Rechargeable Battery.
C. Stun Gun with Light and Alarm: Stun Gun TW10 - Heavy Duty with LED Flashlight Siren Alarm.
D. Stun Gun with Light: TASER StrikeLight 2 Rechargeable Self-Defense Flashlight | Perfect for Running, Jogging, Pet Walking | Portable, Lightweight, Survival, Outdoors.
5. Less than Lethal Gun
A less-than-lethal gun is a self-defense tool designed to temporarily incapacitate or deter an aggressor without causing permanent or fatal harm. Unlike traditional firearms, these devices use non-lethal ammunition and rely on chemical irritants, kinetic energy balls, or other methods to stop a threat. Less-than-lethal guns are a practical option for self-defense, particularly for those who prefer non-lethal methods or live in areas with strict firearm regulations. They offer an effective balance of safety and security.
Characteristics of Less-Than-Lethal Guns
Ammunition Types:
Pepper Balls: Contain a powdered chemical irritant that disperses on impact, causing temporary blindness, difficulty breathing, and severe discomfort.
Kinetic Balls: Solid, non-lethal projectiles designed to deliver a painful impact to discourage further aggression.
Tear Gas Rounds: Emit irritants like CS gas to cause eye, throat, and respiratory distress.
Training Rounds: Safe projectiles for practicing aim and technique.
Range: Typically effective within 20–60 feet, depending on the model and ammunition type.
Design: Often resemble traditional firearms for ease of handling and familiarity. Lightweight and compact, making them easy to carry and conceal.
Power Source: Most are powered by compressed air (CO2 cartridges) or gas systems to propel the projectiles.
Legal Accessibility: Available for purchase in most areas without the need for a firearm license or permit, though regulations vary by location.
Benefits of Less-Than-Lethal Guns
Non-lethal Defense: Provides a way to stop or deter threats without the moral or legal consequences of using a lethal weapon.
Ease of Use: Simple operation makes them accessible to a wide range of users, including those with minimal training.
Reduced Risk: Minimizes the chance of causing accidental or unintended fatal harm.
Versatility: Can be used in situations where traditional firearms might not be appropriate, such as in crowded areas or where deadly force is not justified.
Limitations to Consider
Close Quarters: May require closer proximity than traditional firearms for full effectiveness.
Wind Conditions: Chemical projectiles can be affected by wind, potentially reducing accuracy or causing blowback.
Less than Lethal Gun Options
Fires a variety of projectiles, including pepper balls and kinetic rounds.
Effective range of up to 60 feet.
Compact and lightweight.
Fires chemical irritant rounds such as OC (pepper spray) or CS (tear gas).
Best for close to mid-range use (20–30 feet).
Simple, intuitive design.
REGULATION AND PERMITTED USE
The Byrna/Saber launcher is not a “firearm” under federal law. States and municipalities may regulate possession and use of the Byrna launcher and Byrna projectiles, including transportation in a vehicle, use by certain categories of persons, and use in certain venues. The use of chemical irritant projectiles for any reason other than self-defense is a crime. Possession of compressed CO2 cylinders is regulated in certain venues, including airports. Always check applicable laws and regulations before transporting or using your Byrna launcher.
6. Taser
A Taser is a less-than-lethal self-defense tool designed to incapacitate an attacker from a distance by delivering an electric shock that disrupts the body's neuromuscular system. Tasers are widely used by law enforcement and civilians alike for their ability to immobilize a threat without causing permanent harm. A Taser can be an effective, easy-to-use self-defense tool that provides the ability to stop a threat from a safe distance. It’s particularly useful for those seeking a non-lethal alternative to traditional firearms. While it has limitations, when combined with situational awareness and proper training, a Taser can be a valuable addition to a personal safety plan.
How a Taser Works
Projectile Electrodes: A Taser fires two small, dart-like electrodes attached to thin wires that connect to the device. These darts embed in the target’s clothing or skin, delivering an electrical charge.
Neuromuscular Incapacitation (NMI): The electrical charge interrupts the communication between the brain and muscles, causing involuntary muscle contractions and temporary paralysis.
Effective Range: Most Tasers have an effective range of 10–15 feet, allowing for distance between you and the attacker.
Features of Tasers
Range:
Tasers can immobilize a target from a distance, providing a safety buffer.
Many models also include a "drive-stun" option for close-contact use if needed.
Non-lethal:
Designed to incapacitate without causing long-term harm or fatal injury.
Ease of Use:
Simple controls make them accessible for users with minimal training.
Rechargeable Battery:
Most models are battery-powered and include indicators to show remaining charge.
Integrated Features:
Some Tasers include built-in flashlights and laser sights to improve aim in low-light situations.
Benefits of Using a Taser
Distance Defense: Allows you to neutralize a threat while maintaining a safe distance.
Quick Incapacitation: Delivers immediate results, giving you time to escape or call for help.
Non-lethal Alternative: Ideal for those seeking a less-lethal self-defense tool.
Legal Use: Available to civilians in many areas with fewer restrictions than firearms.
Limitations of Tasers
Limited Range: Effective only at relatively close distances (typically 10–15 feet).
Single-Shot Capability: Most civilian models fire only one set of electrodes, requiring a reload to use again.
Potential Ineffectiveness: May be less effective on individuals wearing thick clothing or under the influence of drugs or alcohol.
Both Darts Must Hit Target: In order for a Taser to work, both darts must hit the intended target. In a high stress, close quarter scenario the Taser will be ineffective.
Legal Restrictions: Tasers are regulated in some areas. Check local laws to ensure you can legally own and carry one.
Best Practices for Using a Taser
Practice: Familiarize yourself with its operation and aim, ensuring you can deploy it effectively in high-stress situations.
Situational Awareness: Use in combination with awareness skills to avoid encounters whenever possible.
Keep Spare Cartridges: Carry extra cartridges in case a reload is necessary.
Taser Option: Professional Series Personal and Home Defense Kit TASER 7CQ
Personal Taser: TASER Bolt 2 Self-Defense Device | Personal Protection Kit
As you can see, there are many “Less than Lethal Self-Defense” options available. However, the most effective strategy is always to be aware of your surroundings and avoid dangerous situations when possible. In a true ambush scenario, the likelihood of being able to access a self-defense tool is slim. Remember, the level of force must match the level of danger, and every situation will be unique. I can’t emphasize enough the importance of mentally rehearsing scenarios throughout your day. For example, if you’re walking from your car to the grocery store, take a moment to consider: How would I react if someone approached me between two cars? What would I do if I were distracted while loading groceries? These are common scenarios worth considering.
Many of these tools also come with inert training options, allowing you to test the device safely without risk of harm to yourself or others. I offer group training sessions where you can practice with these devices and determine which one you’d feel most comfortable deploying in a self-defense situation. Check our schedule for an upcoming class on “Less Than Lethal Training.”
